Climate negotiations in Turkey collapsed after countries failed to agree on phasing out fossil fuels, drawing sharp criticism from the EU and others.
Climate talks in Turkey fell apart on Sunday when countries failed to agree on any mention of fossil fuels in the final deal. The meeting in Antalya ended in deadlock two days past its original deadline, as negotiators could not find common ground after a week of arguments over how to tackle climate change.
The European Union and several other countries walked away from the latest draft agreement, which made no reference to moving away from oil, coal or gas. Ireland’s environment minister Darragh O’Brien, speaking for the EU, said the bloc “strongly objects” to a deal he called “greenwashing.” He said, “It is unconscionable that we would have a climate pact that makes no mention of fossil fuels.” The EU was joined by countries like Panama and the Marshall Islands in rejecting the text.
Disagreements deepen
The COP31 summit was supposed to wrap up on Friday, but talks ran overtime as delegates tried to salvage a deal. The first draft, released a week into the summit, mentioned “fossil fuel” or “fossil fuels” six times. But in later drafts, all references disappeared. The second draft came out Thursday with the words cut, drawing anger from many countries. A fourth draft released on Sunday kept fossil fuels out of the text and was also rejected.
COP31 President Murat Kurum, who is also Turkey’s environment minister, told reporters on Sunday, “There is nothing to do. We did all that we could.” He added, “We will not be carrying out work on a new text in an environment where there is no consensus.” Kurum said he had hoped for a stronger result from the summit.
Chris Bowen, president of the negotiations and an Australian minister, said the talks had hit “unbridgeable red lines.” Bowen pointed to the tense state of global politics as a reason for the breakdown. “Things that were manageable in the past, in previous COPs like the last two where people wanted certain words mentioned but didn’t get them, it became a red line this time,” he said.
Countries like Saudi Arabia, Russia and India opposed any mention of fossil fuels in the agreement. They argued that their economies depend heavily on oil, gas or coal, and that moving away from them too quickly could hurt their finances.
Anger and warnings from affected countries
Panama’s environment minister Juan Carlos Navarro accused major oil-producing nations of holding the talks hostage. “We love the petroleum guys,” Navarro said. “We can’t live without them, and they are so smart, they have convinced us that they are doing this for our own good.” Kate Hughes, the UK’s delegate, called the draft the “lowest common denominator.”
The Marshall Islands, which faces threats from rising seas, also rejected the deal. Mohamed Adow from Power Shift Africa labelled COP31 the “worst ever.” He said, “The collapse of climate talks at COP31 in Antalya needs to be a wake-up call for the world.”
The conference was the longest in the history of COP climate meetings, overtaking the previous record set in Madrid at COP25. All 196 countries plus the EU needed to sign off for a deal to pass. The United States was officially absent from this year’s talks, after stepping back from global climate deals under former President Donald Trump.
The latest draft opened by mentioning last year’s COP28 agreement in the United Arab Emirates, which included a promise to “transition away” from fossil fuels. But the Antalya talks failed to build on that pledge. The document also admitted that the world is likely to miss the 2015 Paris Agreement’s goal of keeping warming below 1.5 degrees Celsius, which scientists say would make dangerous weather more common.
United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres said he was “deeply disappointed that COP31 has ended without consensus on an overarching outcome.” He posted on X, “There may be no consensus in the negotiating room. There is no ambiguity in the science.”
Kurum could still call another meeting or wait for the next annual summit in Ethiopia. The last time climate talks collapsed without a deal was in 2000, at COP6 in The Hague.